Explain why the electron affinity of oxygen has two values — a first electron affinity that is exothermic and a second electron affinity that is endothermic — and discuss how both values are nevertheless incorporated into a Born–Haber cycle to give a valid lattice enthalpy for an ionic oxide such as magnesium oxide.
Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).
Model answer (4 marks)
The first electron affinity of oxygen is exothermic because the incoming electron is attracted to the nuclear charge of the neutral O atom, releasing energy. The second electron affinity is endothermic because the incoming electron is added to an already negatively charged O⁻ ion, so electrostatic repulsion must be overcome, requiring energy input.
In a Born–Haber cycle the two electron affinities are simply added to the other steps. Hess’s law means that the sign of each step is irrelevant – the cycle is a closed loop of enthalpy changes between the same initial and final states. Thus both the exothermic first and the endothermic second electron affinities appear in the cycle.
The lattice enthalpy of MgO is very large and exothermic. When the two electron affinities are combined with the other steps (ionisation of Mg, sublimation of Mg, dissociation of O₂, formation of O²⁻), the large negative lattice enthalpy compensates for the positive second electron affinity, giving a negative overall enthalpy of formation for MgO.
In a Born–Haber cycle the two electron affinities are simply added to the other steps. Hess’s law means that the sign of each step is irrelevant – the cycle is a closed loop of enthalpy changes between the same initial and final states. Thus both the exothermic first and the endothermic second electron affinities appear in the cycle.
The lattice enthalpy of MgO is very large and exothermic. When the two electron affinities are combined with the other steps (ionisation of Mg, sublimation of Mg, dissociation of O₂, formation of O²⁻), the large negative lattice enthalpy compensates for the positive second electron affinity, giving a negative overall enthalpy of formation for MgO.
Examiner tips
- Use the exact terms ‘first electron affinity’, ‘second electron affinity’, ‘exothermic’, ‘endothermic’, ‘Born–Haber cycle’, ‘lattice enthalpy’.
- Show the two electron affinity steps explicitly in the cycle diagram or list, noting their signs.
- Explain that Hess’s law allows inclusion of both steps regardless of sign.
- Mention that the large negative lattice enthalpy offsets the endothermic second electron affinity.
Mark scheme (4 marks)
- The first electron affinity is exothermic because the incoming electron is attracted to the nuclear charge of the neutral oxygen atom, releasing energy.
- The second electron affinity is endothermic because the incoming electron is being added to an already negatively charged O⁻ ion, so electrostatic repulsion must be overcome, requiring energy input.
- Hess's law allows both electron affinities to be included in the Born–Haber cycle regardless of their sign, because the cycle is simply an application of conservation of energy / enthalpy along different pathways between the same initial and final states.
- The large exothermic lattice enthalpy of MgO (energy released when gaseous Mg²⁺ and O²⁻ ions form the lattice) is sufficiently large in magnitude to compensate for the endothermic second electron affinity, making the overall formation of MgO energetically feasible.
Key terms in this question
electron affinity · Born–Haber cycle · lattice enthalpy
Related
- All IB DP Chemistry Higher Level (2023 syllabus) revision notes →
- How to answer a "Explain" question →
- Decode the mark scheme abbreviations →