Explain why passive immunity provides only short-term protection against disease, whilst active immunity provides long-term protection.
Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).
Model answer (4 marks)
Passive immunity gives only short‑term protection because it relies on antibodies that are transferred from another individual or source; these antibodies are eventually degraded and are not produced by the recipient’s immune system, so no memory cells are formed.
In contrast, active immunity involves the recipient’s own immune system recognising the antigen and producing specific antibodies. This process generates memory B and T cells that persist for years. When the same antigen re‑enters the body, these memory cells recognise it immediately and trigger a rapid, robust antibody response, providing long‑term protection.
In contrast, active immunity involves the recipient’s own immune system recognising the antigen and producing specific antibodies. This process generates memory B and T cells that persist for years. When the same antigen re‑enters the body, these memory cells recognise it immediately and trigger a rapid, robust antibody response, providing long‑term protection.
Examiner tips
- Use the terms ‘memory cells’ and ‘antibodies’ explicitly. Explain the difference in source of antibodies (transferred vs. produced). Mention degradation of passive antibodies and persistence of memory cells. Keep the answer concise and directly linked to the marks.
Common mistakes
- Confusing passive with active immunity by saying both involve antibody production. Forgetting to mention that passive antibodies are broken down. Using vague phrases like ‘short‑term’ without explaining why.
Mark scheme (4 marks)
- Passive immunity does not involve the production of memory cells
- In passive immunity, antibodies are transferred from another individual / source and are eventually broken down
- Active immunity results in the production of memory cells
- Memory cells remain in the body for years / recognise the same antigen on re-infection and produce antibodies rapidly, giving long-term immunity
Key terms in this question
passive immunity · active immunity
Related
- All Cambridge International IGCSE Biology (0610) revision notes →
- How to answer a "Explain" question →
- Decode the mark scheme abbreviations →
More Diseases and immunity questions
- Describe how white blood cells defend the body after a pathogen has entered the …
- Vaccination is used to protect individuals against transmissible diseases. Expla…
- A mother breastfeeds her newborn baby. Explain why the immunity the baby receive…
- Describe how the body responds when a pathogen enters the bloodstream for the fi…