Explain why a uniform solid cylinder and a uniform hollow cylinder of the same mass and outer radius, released simultaneously from rest at the top of an inclined plane, reach the bottom at different times, even though no energy is lost to friction that causes slipping.

IB DP Physics Higher Level (2023 syllabus) — A.4 Rigid body mechanics (HL only) · Explain · 4 marks · View as Markdown

Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).

Model answer (4 marks)

A uniform solid cylinder and a uniform hollow cylinder of the same mass and outer radius, when released from rest on an incline, both roll without slipping. The gravitational potential energy lost is converted into translational kinetic energy frac12mv^2 and rotational kinetic energy frac12Iomega^2, with omega=v/r. For a given mass and radius the hollow cylinder has a larger moment of inertia I_hollow> I_solid because its mass is farther from the axis. Thus, for the same linear speed v, a larger fraction of the energy is stored as rotational kinetic energy in the hollow cylinder, leaving less energy for translational motion. Consequently the hollow cylinder has a smaller linear acceleration down the slope and reaches the bottom later than the solid cylinder.

Examiner tips

  • Use the relationship I_hollow> I_solid for equal m and R; link I to the fraction of energy in rotation; state that less translational KE gives lower acceleration; mention no slipping friction only provides the torque.
  • Show the energy conversion equation and the I values to justify the difference in acceleration.

Common mistakes

  • Confusing moment of inertia with mass; writing I_solid>I_hollow; ignoring that both roll without slipping; failing to connect higher I to lower translational acceleration.

Mark scheme (4 marks)

  1. Rolling without slipping converts gravitational potential energy into both translational kinetic energy and rotational kinetic energy.
  2. The hollow cylinder has a greater moment of inertia than the solid cylinder (for the same mass and outer radius) because more of its mass is distributed farther from the rotational axis.
  3. For a given linear speed, a greater moment of inertia means more energy is stored as rotational kinetic energy, so less energy is available for translational kinetic energy.
  4. Therefore the hollow cylinder has a lower translational (linear) acceleration down the slope and arrives at the bottom after the solid cylinder.

Related

More Rigid body mechanics (HL only) questions

▶ Try answering this question with AI marking (free) →