Explain why a large multicellular organism cannot rely solely on diffusion across its outer body surface to meet its oxygen demands, whereas a single-celled organism such as Amoeba can.
Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).
Model answer (4 marks)
Large multicellular organisms have a smaller surface area to volume ratio than small organisms, so the amount of oxygen that can diffuse in per unit volume is limited.
The volume of respiring tissue is too great relative to the surface area available for diffusion, meaning the metabolic demand cannot be met.
Diffusion distance from the outer surface to inner cells is too great, so oxygen cannot reach all cells quickly enough by diffusion alone.
In contrast, a single‑cell organism such as an amoeba has a high surface area to volume ratio and all parts of the cell are close to the external surface, so diffusion distance is short and enough oxygen can diffuse in to meet its demand.
The volume of respiring tissue is too great relative to the surface area available for diffusion, meaning the metabolic demand cannot be met.
Diffusion distance from the outer surface to inner cells is too great, so oxygen cannot reach all cells quickly enough by diffusion alone.
In contrast, a single‑cell organism such as an amoeba has a high surface area to volume ratio and all parts of the cell are close to the external surface, so diffusion distance is short and enough oxygen can diffuse in to meet its demand.
Examiner tips
- Use the term ‘surface area to volume ratio’ and explain its effect on diffusion.
- Mention both the limited surface area and the long diffusion distance in large organisms.
- Show the contrast with the short diffusion distance in a single‑cell organism.
Common mistakes
- Failing to mention the surface area to volume ratio.
- Confusing diffusion distance with overall size without linking to oxygen demand.
- Using vague phrases like ‘too big’ instead of specific reasons.
Mark scheme (4 marks)
- Large organisms have a smaller surface area to volume ratio compared to small organisms
- The volume of respiring tissue (metabolic demand) is too great relative to the surface area available for diffusion
- Diffusion distance from the outer surface to inner cells is too great in a large organism, so oxygen cannot reach all cells quickly enough by diffusion alone
- In Amoeba, all parts of the cell are close to the external surface so diffusion distance is short, and the high surface area to volume ratio means enough oxygen can diffuse in to meet demand
Key terms in this question
diffusion · multicellular · single-celled
Related
- All OCR A-Level Biology A (H420) revision notes →
- How to answer a "Explain" question →
- Decode the mark scheme abbreviations →
More Exchange surfaces questions
- Explain why a single-celled organism such as Amoeba can rely solely on diffusion…
- Explain why a large multicellular organism, such as a mammal, requires a special…
- Explain why a large multicellular organism, such as a mammal, requires a special…
- Explain why the gills of a fish are an effective exchange surface for gas exchan…