A student investigates two hydrocarbons: ethane and ethene. Ethene is an unsaturated hydrocarbon, whereas ethane is a saturated hydrocarbon. Explain how the student could use bromine water to distinguish between ethane and ethene, and explain why the two hydrocarbons react differently with bromine water.
Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).
Ethane has the molecular formula C₂H₆. Ethene has the molecular formula C₂H₄. Both are hydrocarbons found in the products of cracking long-chain alkanes.
Model answer (5 marks)
Add a small amount of bromine water to each hydrocarbon (or bubble each gas through bromine water). The orange–brown colour of the bromine water disappears when it is bubbled through ethene, showing that ethene decolourises the solution. In contrast, the colour of the bromine water remains unchanged when ethene is bubbled through ethane, indicating that ethane does not decolourise the solution.
Ethene is unsaturated and contains a C=C double bond. The double bond opens during an addition reaction, allowing Br₂ to add across the bond and form 1,2‑dibromoethane, which removes the bromine colour. Ethane is saturated and has only C–H and C–C single bonds; it cannot undergo addition reactions, so bromine remains in solution and the colour is retained.
Ethene is unsaturated and contains a C=C double bond. The double bond opens during an addition reaction, allowing Br₂ to add across the bond and form 1,2‑dibromoethane, which removes the bromine colour. Ethane is saturated and has only C–H and C–C single bonds; it cannot undergo addition reactions, so bromine remains in solution and the colour is retained.
Examiner tips
- Show the two steps – add bromine water, observe colour change; explain the addition mechanism for ethene and the lack of it for ethane.
- Use the exact terms "unsaturated" and "saturated", "double bond" and "addition reaction" to match the mark scheme.
- Mention the colour change (orange/brown to colourless) for ethene and no change for ethane.
Common mistakes
- Confusing decolourisation with bleaching of the bromine water; students may write that the bromine is consumed rather than the colour change.
- Using the wrong terminology – e.g., calling ethane unsaturated or describing a substitution reaction for ethene.
- Failing to mention the double bond as the reason for the different reactivity.
Mark scheme (5 marks)
- Add bromine water to each hydrocarbon (or bubble each gas through bromine water)
- Ethene decolourises / decolorises the bromine water (orange/brown to colourless)
- Ethane does not decolourise / decolorize the bromine water (stays orange/brown)
- Ethene is unsaturated and contains a carbon–carbon double bond (C=C)
- The double bond in ethene opens / breaks, allowing bromine to add across the double bond (addition reaction); ethane has only single bonds so cannot undergo addition
Key terms in this question
hydrocarbon · saturated · unsaturated · bromine water
Related
- All OCR A-Level Chemistry A (H432) revision notes →
- How to answer a "Explain" question →
- Decode the mark scheme abbreviations →