A student has two materials, steel and soft iron, and wants to use one of them to make a permanent magnet and the other as the core of an electromagnet. State which material should be used for each purpose and explain why each material is suited to its role.
Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).
Model answer (4 marks)
Steel should be used to make the permanent magnet.
Steel is a magnetically hard material; it retains its magnetisation after the external field is removed, so it can act as a permanent magnet.
Soft iron should be used as the core of the electromagnet.
Soft iron is a magnetically soft material; it becomes strongly magnetised when a current is passed but loses its magnetisation quickly when the current is switched off, making it ideal for an electromagnet core.
Steel is a magnetically hard material; it retains its magnetisation after the external field is removed, so it can act as a permanent magnet.
Soft iron should be used as the core of the electromagnet.
Soft iron is a magnetically soft material; it becomes strongly magnetised when a current is passed but loses its magnetisation quickly when the current is switched off, making it ideal for an electromagnet core.
Examiner tips
- Use the terms ‘magnetically hard’ and ‘magnetically soft’ to show understanding of material properties.
- State clearly which material is used for each role before explaining why.
Common mistakes
- Confusing steel with iron or vice‑versa; students may say ‘iron’ for the permanent magnet.
- Failing to mention the retention of magnetisation for steel or the quick loss for soft iron.
Mark scheme (4 marks)
- Steel should be used to make the permanent magnet
- Steel is magnetically hard, so it retains / keeps its magnetism permanently
- Soft iron should be used as the core of the electromagnet
- Soft iron is magnetically soft, so it loses its magnetism quickly / easily when the current is switched off
Key terms in this question
Related
- All Pearson Edexcel International GCSE Physics (4PH1) revision notes →
- How to answer a "Explain" question →
- Decode the mark scheme abbreviations →
More Magnetism questions
- A compass needle is placed near a bar magnet. Describe what is meant by a magnet…
- A student places an unmagnetised iron nail and an unmagnetised steel nail into t…
- A student strokes an unmagnetised cobalt rod several times in the same direction…
- A steel paper clip is held close to, but not touching, the north pole of a perma…