A security scanner at an airport uses X-rays to image the contents of passengers' luggage. A passenger asks why X-rays are used rather than radio waves, which are also electromagnetic waves. Explain why X-rays are suitable for this purpose and describe the health risk associated with repeated exposure to X-rays for the airport security staff who operate the scanner.
Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).
Airport security scanners transmit electromagnetic radiation through luggage to produce an image of the contents inside.
Model answer (5 marks)
X‑rays have a very short wavelength (≈0.01–10 nm) and high frequency, so they can penetrate the soft materials that make up most luggage and are absorbed by denser objects such as metal or bone. The absorption pattern gives a clear image of the contents. Radio waves, with wavelengths of metres to kilometres, are far too long and have too low energy to penetrate the luggage or to be absorbed differentially by small objects, so they cannot produce a useful image.
X‑rays are ionising radiation. When they pass through tissue they transfer enough energy to break chemical bonds and ionise atoms. This can damage DNA and other cellular structures, leading to mutations. Repeated or prolonged exposure to X‑rays increases the cumulative dose and therefore raises the risk of cancer for the staff who operate the scanners.
X‑rays are ionising radiation. When they pass through tissue they transfer enough energy to break chemical bonds and ionise atoms. This can damage DNA and other cellular structures, leading to mutations. Repeated or prolonged exposure to X‑rays increases the cumulative dose and therefore raises the risk of cancer for the staff who operate the scanners.
Examiner tips
- Mention the short wavelength and high energy of X‑rays for penetration and imaging
- Explain ionising nature and DNA damage for health risk
- Show link between repeated exposure and cancer risk
- Use exact terms: ‘penetrate’, ‘absorb’, ‘ionising’, ‘mutation’, ‘cancer’
Common mistakes
- Confusing radio waves with microwaves or infrared; forgetting that radio waves cannot image small objects
- Lacking explanation that X‑rays are ionising and can damage DNA
- Not linking repeated exposure to increased cancer risk
Mark scheme (5 marks)
- X-rays can pass through/penetrate materials (such as luggage/soft materials) to reveal internal structure
- Radio waves are not suitable because they do not penetrate / interact with the contents in the same way OR radio waves have too long a wavelength / too low a frequency to image small objects inside luggage
- X-rays transfer energy to cells in the body (because they have high frequency / high energy)
- This can cause mutation of cells / damage to cells
- Repeated / prolonged exposure increases the risk of cancer
Key terms in this question
X-rays · electromagnetic waves
Related
- All Edexcel A-Level Physics (9PH0) revision notes →
- How to answer a "Explain" question →
- Decode the mark scheme abbreviations →
More Quantum physics questions
- A student is comparing the uses and dangers of ultraviolet (UV) radiation and X-…
- A student is investigating ultraviolet (UV) radiation and visible light. The stu…
- A doctor uses gamma rays to treat a patient's cancer. After the treatment, the p…
- A student states: 'All electromagnetic waves are dangerous to humans because the…