A physicist is studying the photoelectric effect using a clean caesium metal surface. They use a source that emits red light of very high intensity and find that no electrons are emitted from the caesium surface. The physicist then replaces the red light with a source that emits blue light of much lower intensity and finds that electrons are emitted immediately. Explain why electrons are emitted with the blue light but not with the red light, even though the red light has a much higher intensity.

WJEC A-Level Physics (Wales) — 3.2 Photon and particle properties · Explain · 5 marks · View as Markdown

Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).

Model answer (5 marks)

Light reaches the surface as photons, each carrying a fixed amount of energy E=hf, where f is the light frequency.

The intensity of a beam is proportional to the number of photons per unit time, not to the energy of each photon.

Blue light has a higher frequency than red light, so each blue photon has a larger energy.

An electron can be emitted only if a single photon supplies energy greater than the work function (ϕ) of caesium.

Red photons have insufficient energy (hf_red<ϕ) and therefore cannot eject electrons, no matter how many photons are present; increasing intensity does not help because photons cannot combine their energies.

Thus electrons are emitted with blue light but not with red light.

Examiner tips

  • Mention the photon energy formula E=hf; link frequency to colour. Explain that intensity ≠ photon energy. State the work function requirement. Show that many low‑energy photons cannot replace one high‑energy photon.

Common mistakes

  • Confusing intensity with photon energy. Saying that more photons can give more energy. Forgetting to mention the work function or the need for a single photon to exceed it.

Mark scheme (5 marks)

  1. Light travels as photons (discrete packets/quanta of energy)
  2. The energy of a photon depends on the frequency (or colour) of the light, not the intensity
  3. Blue light has a higher frequency than red light, so each blue photon carries more energy
  4. A single photon must have enough energy to exceed the work function of caesium to release one electron
  5. Red photons have insufficient energy to overcome the work function, so no electrons are emitted regardless of intensity (more red photons cannot help because photons do not combine their energy)

Key terms in this question

intensity · photoelectric effect

Related

More Photon and particle properties questions

▶ Try answering this question with AI marking (free) →