A footballer suffers a serious knee injury that destroys cartilage cells. A doctor explains that adult stem cells from the patient's own body could be used to repair the damaged tissue. Explain why adult stem cells from the patient's own body are used in this treatment rather than embryonic stem cells, and describe the process by which the stem cells would produce new cartilage cells.
Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).
Model answer (4 marks)
Adult stem cells are used because they are genetically identical to the patient, so the immune system is unlikely to recognise them as foreign and reject them. In contrast, embryonic stem cells would be rejected and their use also raises ethical problems, as embryos must be destroyed to obtain the cells.
The adult stem cells are isolated from the patient’s own tissue and then introduced into the damaged knee. They first divide by mitosis to increase their number. After division, the cells undergo differentiation, during which they become specialised chondrocytes – the cells that produce cartilage matrix. The differentiated cells then synthesise the collagen and proteoglycan components of cartilage, restoring the damaged tissue.
The adult stem cells are isolated from the patient’s own tissue and then introduced into the damaged knee. They first divide by mitosis to increase their number. After division, the cells undergo differentiation, during which they become specialised chondrocytes – the cells that produce cartilage matrix. The differentiated cells then synthesise the collagen and proteoglycan components of cartilage, restoring the damaged tissue.
Examiner tips
- Mention genetic identity to avoid rejection
- State ethical issue with embryonic stem cells
- Explain mitotic division and subsequent differentiation into chondrocytes
Common mistakes
- Confusing embryonic with adult stem cells as the source
- Failing to mention the ethical concern with embryos
- Not describing the mitotic division step
Mark scheme (4 marks)
- Adult stem cells are less likely to be rejected because they come from the patient's own body (genetically identical to the patient)
- Using embryonic stem cells raises ethical concerns / embryos are destroyed to obtain them
- Cell differentiation — the undifferentiated stem cells differentiate / become specialised
- The stem cells divide by mitosis (before or during differentiation) to produce new cells / increase the number of cells available
Key terms in this question
adult stem cells · embryonic stem cells
Related
- Revision notes: Cell differentiation, growth and stem cells →
- How to answer a "Explain" question →
- Decode the mark scheme abbreviations →
More Cell differentiation, growth and stem cells questions
- Explain why embryonic stem cells are considered more useful than adult stem cell…
- A scientist is growing human skin tissue in a laboratory to help treat patients …
- A patient has been diagnosed with a blood disorder caused by faulty red blood ce…
- Describe how meristem tissue in plants is related to cell differentiation and ex…