A firefighter stands on a stationary boat floating on a calm lake. The firefighter jumps horizontally off the front of the boat onto a jetty. Explain why the boat moves backwards as the firefighter jumps forwards. Your answer must refer to momentum.

Eduqas A-Level Physics — 1.4 Momentum (A-Level only) · Explain · 5 marks · View as Markdown

Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).

The total mass of the firefighter and boat together is 120 kg. Before the jump, the firefighter and the boat are both stationary.

Model answer (5 marks)

Before the jump the firefighter and the boat are stationary, so the total momentum of the system is zero.

When the firefighter jumps forwards, his momentum becomes
(p_{ ext{firefighter}} = m_{ ext{firefighter}};v_{ ext{firefighter}}) in the forward direction.

Because no external horizontal forces act on the system, momentum is conserved. Therefore the boat must acquire an equal and opposite momentum:
(p_{ ext{boat}} = -p_{ ext{firefighter}}) in the backward direction.

Since the boat’s mass (120 kg) is much larger than the firefighter’s mass, the boat’s speed (v_{ ext{boat}} = p_{ ext{boat}}/m_{ ext{boat}}) is much smaller than the firefighter’s speed. Hence the boat moves backwards slowly while the firefighter moves forwards.

Examiner tips

  • Show the initial momentum is zero, then state conservation of momentum, then calculate the boat’s momentum as the negative of the firefighter’s, and finally explain the speed difference using the mass ratio.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming the boat moves forward, or ignoring that the boat’s momentum is opposite to the firefighter’s; forgetting to mention conservation of momentum; not recognising that the boat’s speed is lower because of its larger mass.

Mark scheme (5 marks)

  1. Before the jump, the total momentum of the system (firefighter + boat) is zero
  2. Momentum is conserved (the total momentum of the system remains the same / is constant)
  3. The firefighter gains momentum in the forward direction (as they jump forwards)
  4. The boat must gain an equal and opposite momentum (in the backward direction) so the total remains zero
  5. Because the boat has a larger mass than the firefighter, it moves backwards more slowly (lower speed than the firefighter's forward speed)

Key terms in this question

momentum

Related

More Momentum (A-Level only) questions

▶ Try answering this question with AI marking (free) →