A doctor uses ultrasound waves to scan a patient for a kidney stone. The ultrasound pulse travels into the body and is partially reflected at the boundary between soft tissue and the kidney stone, returning to a receiver on the skin. Explain how the doctor is able to detect the kidney stone using this method, and explain why ultrasound is preferred over X-rays for this type of repeated scanning.

OCR A-Level Physics A (H556) — 5.1 Thermal physics · Explain · 5 marks · View as Markdown

Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).

Ultrasound waves have a frequency higher than 20 kHz, which is above the upper limit of human hearing. When they reach a boundary between two different media inside the body, they are partially reflected back to a receiver placed on the skin surface.

Model answer (5 marks)

Ultrasound waves are generated by a transducer and travel through the body. When the wave reaches the interface between soft tissue and a kidney stone, part of the wave is reflected back because the acoustic impedance of the stone is different from that of the tissue.

The speed of the ultrasound in soft tissue is essentially constant (≈ 1540 m s⁻¹). By measuring the time interval between the emission of the pulse and the detection of the reflected echo, the doctor can calculate the distance to the stone using d = ½ v t.

The receiver records many such echoes from different depths and angles; these signals are processed to form a two‑dimensional image, allowing the stone’s position and size to be visualised.

X‑rays are ionising radiation; their high frequency and energy can break chemical bonds in DNA, causing mutations and increasing cancer risk. Ultrasound, being non‑ionising, does not damage cells, making it safe for repeated examinations.

Thus the doctor detects the stone by measuring reflected ultrasound echoes and prefers ultrasound because it is harmless and can be used repeatedly without radiation risk.

Examiner tips

  • Use the term ‘acoustic impedance’ to show understanding of why reflection occurs.
  • Show the echo‑time calculation (d = ½ v t) to demonstrate use of constant speed.
  • Mention image formation from multiple echoes to justify localisation.
  • Contrast ionising vs non‑ionising radiation to justify safety.

Common mistakes

  • Confusing the speed of sound in air with that in tissue.
  • Forgetting the factor ½ in the distance calculation.
  • Claiming ultrasound is ionising or that X‑rays are safe for repeated use.

Mark scheme (5 marks)

  1. Ultrasound waves are partially reflected at the boundary between two different media (e.g. tissue and kidney stone)
  2. The speed of the ultrasound waves is constant, so the time between emission and detection of the reflected waves can be used to determine the depth / distance of the kidney stone
  3. The reflected waves are detected by the receiver and used to build up an image / locate the kidney stone
  4. X-rays can cause cell damage / mutations / cancer because they have high frequency and high energy
  5. Ultrasound does not cause cell damage / is non-ionising, so it is safe to use repeatedly

Key terms in this question

ultrasound waves · boundary · partially reflected · X-rays

Related

More Thermal physics questions

▶ Try answering this question with AI marking (free) →