A chocolate manufacturer heats solid chocolate in a large vat until it melts completely. Once all the chocolate has melted, the manufacturer notices that the mass of the liquid chocolate is the same as the mass of the solid chocolate before heating. Explain why the mass is conserved during this change of state, and describe how the physical properties of the chocolate differ between the solid and liquid states in terms of particles.
Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).
A chocolate manufacturer heats solid chocolate in a large vat until it melts completely. The manufacturer records the mass before and after melting and finds it is unchanged.
Model answer (4 marks)
Melting is a physical change, so no chemical reaction occurs and no particles are created or destroyed – the mass of the chocolate therefore remains the same.
During melting the chocolate is heated until the temperature reaches its melting point. The energy supplied increases the kinetic energy of the particles until the attractive forces that hold them in a fixed lattice are overcome.
In the solid state the particles are tightly packed in a regular arrangement and can only vibrate about fixed positions, held together by strong intermolecular forces.
In the liquid state the particles are still in contact but are free to move past one another; they can flow and take the shape of the container while the intermolecular forces still act between them.
Because the particles are merely rearranged and not destroyed, the mass is conserved.
During melting the chocolate is heated until the temperature reaches its melting point. The energy supplied increases the kinetic energy of the particles until the attractive forces that hold them in a fixed lattice are overcome.
In the solid state the particles are tightly packed in a regular arrangement and can only vibrate about fixed positions, held together by strong intermolecular forces.
In the liquid state the particles are still in contact but are free to move past one another; they can flow and take the shape of the container while the intermolecular forces still act between them.
Because the particles are merely rearranged and not destroyed, the mass is conserved.
Examiner tips
- Use the term ‘physical change’ and mention no particles are created or destroyed. Explain the role of temperature and kinetic energy. Describe particle arrangement in solid vs liquid. Show that the chocolate can be re‑solidified with the same mass.
Common mistakes
- Saying the chocolate is chemically altered. Forgetting to mention that particles are still in contact in the liquid. Using vague terms like ‘moved around’ instead of ‘flow over each other’.
Mark scheme (4 marks)
- Melting is a physical change, not a chemical change, so no particles are created or destroyed.
- The change of state is reversible and the chocolate retains its original properties when re-solidified.
- In the solid state, particles are tightly packed together and can only vibrate about their fixed positions, held by strong intermolecular forces.
- In the liquid state, particles are still in contact but can flow over each other, with intermolecular forces still acting between them.
Key terms in this question
Related
- All OCR GCSE Physics A: Gateway Science (J249) revision notes →
- How to answer a "Explain" question →
- Decode the mark scheme abbreviations →
More Changes of state questions
- A student is heating a block of ice. At first, the temperature of the ice rises.…
- Explain why the temperature of boiling water does not rise above 100 °C even whe…
- Dry ice is solid carbon dioxide. At room temperature, dry ice undergoes sublimat…
- A nurse removes a sealed bag of saline solution from a freezer. The bag contains…