1-chloropropane can react with aqueous sodium hydroxide to form propan-1-ol. However, when 1-chloropropane reacts with ethanolic sodium hydroxide instead, a different type of reaction occurs and propene is formed. Explain why changing the solvent changes the type of reaction that takes place, and describe the difference between the two reactions.
Written & reviewed by James Millett — Biology (Imperial College London), PGCE Science (University of Cambridge).
1-chloropropane undergoes different reactions depending on whether aqueous or ethanolic sodium hydroxide is used as the reagent.
Model answer (5 marks)
1-chloropropane reacts with aqueous NaOH via a nucleophilic substitution (S_N2). The hydroxide ion (OH⁻) is a strong nucleophile and attacks the electrophilic carbon bearing the chlorine, displacing Cl⁻ and giving propan‑1‑ol.
In ethanolic NaOH the solvent is polar protic but less able to stabilise the transition state for substitution. The hydroxide ion behaves mainly as a strong base. It abstracts a β‑hydrogen from the 2‑carbon of 1‑chloropropane, while the C–Cl bond breaks to give a double bond. This is an E2 elimination, producing propene.
Thus the change of solvent changes the reaction from a nucleophilic substitution to a base‑promoted elimination, giving an alcohol in water and an alkene in ethanol.
In ethanolic NaOH the solvent is polar protic but less able to stabilise the transition state for substitution. The hydroxide ion behaves mainly as a strong base. It abstracts a β‑hydrogen from the 2‑carbon of 1‑chloropropane, while the C–Cl bond breaks to give a double bond. This is an E2 elimination, producing propene.
Thus the change of solvent changes the reaction from a nucleophilic substitution to a base‑promoted elimination, giving an alcohol in water and an alkene in ethanol.
Examiner tips
- Mention OH⁻ as nucleophile in water, base in ethanol; state S_N2 vs E2; note product differences; keep answer concise
Common mistakes
- Confusing the role of OH⁻ as nucleophile in both solvents; not specifying E2 mechanism; writing the wrong product for the ethanolic reaction
Mark scheme (5 marks)
- Aqueous sodium hydroxide provides hydroxide ions (OH⁻) that act as a nucleophile
- In aqueous conditions the reaction is nucleophilic substitution, where the OH⁻ replaces the chlorine atom
- Ethanolic sodium hydroxide provides hydroxide ions that act as a base
- In ethanolic conditions the reaction is elimination, where a hydrogen atom and the chlorine atom are removed from adjacent carbon atoms
- Elimination produces a C=C double bond, forming an alkene (propene)
Related
- All WJEC A-Level Chemistry (Wales) revision notes →
- How to answer a "Explain" question →
- Decode the mark scheme abbreviations →
More Halogenoalkanes questions
- 1-bromopropane can react with ethanolic potassium hydroxide to produce an alkene…
- Chloroethane can be converted into ethanol by reacting it with aqueous sodium hy…
- Bromoethane can undergo a substitution reaction with potassium cyanide solution …
- 1-iodopropane can react with ammonia solution to form an organic product. Descri…